The Stone City

Words Made to Last

Monday, February 26, 2007

Justification

Megan McArdle goes badly wrong in attempting to reconcile cultural relativism with her opposition to some forms of barbarity:
That is not to say that these cultural traist should be allowed to continue; I think [female genital mutilation] should be stamped out, because people shouldn't be able to make those kinds of permanent decisions for their children.
[Emphasis mine.] This completely begs the question of what "those kinds" of decisions are. Orthodontic braces, for example, are a permanent decision which I presume does not require stamping out.

This is not about choice, but about a culture of subjugation supported by barbaric cruelty. Miss McArdle has clumsily tried to bury this point, but it cannot be avoided.